Go homepage(回首页) Upload pictures (上传图片) Write articles (发文字帖)
The author:(作者)delvpublished in(发表于) 2013/10/31 9:32:45 Lawyers said Hu Wanlin under tuition money was arrested for fraud
"God" dead 22 year old students not qualified TCM class charging fictitious "cure-all" lawyer--
"Magic doctor" suspected at least two deadly sins
Illegal medical practice, Hu Wanlin was sentenced to 15 years jail upon release back. Is a 22 year old students were killed. Curriculum vitae of Hu Wanlin and prisons and treating the dead has a close relationship, makes no conceive is that this "magic doctor" coats cheats, happy why so long.
News playback
On August 31, Hu Wanlin shortly released, the name "magic doctor" flag, arrived at Longtan Gorge scenic area in Xin′an County, Henan province a farmhouse hotel, ready to give students "health origami".
Class, Hu Wanlin gave participants he made "mixed soup," says this soup will cure all ills. 22 years of us drank "God" has died after.
Experts say the suspected this soup is made up of several kitchen spices and Glauber's salt. Mirabilite as a strong laxative, improper usage could easily lead the body dehydration, even life-threatening.
On September 30, Hu Wanlin was arrested for illegal medical practice crime, Xin′an County Procuratorate approved the arrest.
It is understood that Hu Wanlin advertising primarily through QQ, called training, fee is 10,000 USD, defrayed by the participants.
Followers of Hu Wanlin said 10,000 yuan fee charged by Hu, is generally voluntary. Learning circles also said that in traditional Chinese medicine, unified standard tuition-free, celebrity charging higher and higher.
Followers of Hu, currently in the country, as many as hundreds of so-called training, courses of traditional Chinese medicine.
Interpretation of law
At least constitute a crime of negligence causing death
Criminal Law Research Institute of Beijing Normal University Professor yinjianfeng said, "the crime of illegal medical practice" means the illegal practice of not qualified as a medical practitioner, if the circumstances are serious. Opened illegally engaged in the diagnosis, treatment, medical care, and so on.
Hu Wanlin was described to members with the training much more water, exhale "treatments", having given the configuration of five flavors "soup", it is difficult to identify "illegal practice".
Hu Wanlin whether they constitute "intentional homicide", this depends on the victim's death is the result of intent. From the perspective of the facts in the present case, identified Hu Wanlin directly to the cloud some results for a positive wish of death intentionally, a lack of supporting evidence.
There is an "indirect intention", and refers to knowing the behavior occurs socially harmful results, and letting this happen.
Hu Wanlin of the victim's death was the result of indirect intent, constitute indirect intentional homicide; if it is negligence, would constitute a crime of negligence causing death.
Fictitious "cure-all" for deception
Criminal Law Committee of the Beijing Municipal Lawyers Association Secretary General Liu Ling said Hu Wanlin does not have medical qualifications, no medical knowledge, and many times death due to illegal practices, is imposing a penalty.
But the concealed the truth, again to "doctor" emerged, made up facts to cure all diseases, implemented a series of fraud, such as false advertising on the Internet can heal all diseases, encouraging others to participate in its teaching courses in order to achieve "tuition" gain in the name property.
These acts makes the victims have misconceptions, know the truth of the situation to dispose of personal property, property damage, Hu Wanlin unlawful possession of the property of others purposes are achieved.
According to the criminal law provisions, Hu Wanlin under tuition cheat student property, may be suspected of fraud.
Through the QQ Group of students is illegal
Liu Ling lawyers say, from teaching, start with the health administration departments certified qualifications. Before the class instruction, also need to apply to the education sector for the record, charge to industry and commerce, to register with the tax authorities.
It is clear that Hu Wanlin does not have the appropriate qualifications, nor in accordance with the administrative rules and regulations apply to the relevant authorities accordingly. Therefore, Hu Wanlin classes to teach traditional Chinese medicine treatments are illegal.
At the same time, Hu Wanlin practicing medicine illegally in 2000 and sentenced to 15 years ' imprisonment, release time is not known. If the crime occurred in the sentence is completed in 5 years, and will also be sentenced to penalties above, Hu Wanlin recidivism, from severe punishment according to law.
Victims ' relatives can claim civil compensation
Yinjianfeng Professor, criminal procedure law, the victim suffered material damage due to the defendant's criminal conduct, in the course of criminal proceedings, the right to bring civil suit collateral. The victim's death, near relatives of the victims have the right to bring civil suit collateral, may apply to the Court at the same time, take measures of Conservancy, sealing up, distraint or freezing the property of the defendant.
In this case, criminal cases have been registered, the victim's family has the right to bring civil suit collateral, ask Hu Wanlin compensation for their losses.
Text/journalist Wang Hong intern double
Legal evening news(律师称胡万林以收学费名义谋取钱财涉嫌诈骗罪|胡万林|故意杀人|神医_新闻资讯2013年10月30日14:04（编辑：SN094）
“神汤”喝死22岁学员没资质开中医班收费虚构“包治百病”律师解读——
“神医”至少涉嫌两宗罪
因非法行医，被判处有期徒刑15年的胡万林刑满出狱后，重操旧业。这次被害死的是一位22岁的大学生。胡万林的履历和监狱、治死人有着不解之缘，可让人想不通的是，这个披着“神医”外衣的骗子，为什么能逍遥那么久。
新闻回放
8月31日，刑满释放不久的胡万林，打着“神医”旗号，抵达河南新安县龙潭峡景区一农家宾馆，准备给学员们做“养生中医讲座”。
课上，胡万林给学员们喝了他配制的“五味汤”，称此汤可以治百病。22岁的云旭阳喝了“神汤”后却因抢救无效死亡。
专家称，此汤疑似由几种厨房调料和芒硝组成。芒硝为强烈泻药，用法不当易造成人体脱水，甚至危及生命。
9月30日，胡万林因涉嫌非法行医罪，被新安县检察院批准逮捕。
据了解，胡万林主要通过QQ做宣传，召集学员培训，费用定价为1万元，食宿费由学员单出。
胡万林的信徒说，胡收取的1万元费用，都是大家自愿交的。还说在中医的学习圈里，学费无统一标准，名气越大收费越高。
胡的信徒称，目前在全国，有多达上百个所谓中医培训、学习班。
法律解读
至少构成过失致人死亡罪
北京师范大学刑事法律科学研究院教授阴建峰说，“非法行医罪”是指未取得医生执业资格者非法行医，情节严重的行为。如非法开业从事诊断、治疗、医务护理等。
胡万林只是在培训中向随行人员讲述多喝水、多吐故纳新的“治疗方法”，让学员服用其配置的“五味汤”，难以认定为“非法行医”。
胡万林的行为是否构成“故意杀人罪”，关键在于其对于被害人死亡的结果是否出于故意。从本案现有事实看，认定胡万林对云某死亡结果出于积极希望的直接故意，缺乏证据支持。
还有一种是“间接故意”，是指明知自己的行为会发生危害社会的结果，而放任这种结果发生。
如果胡万林对被害人死亡的结果是出于间接故意，就构成间接故意杀人罪；如果是出于过失，就构成过失致人死亡罪。
虚构“包治百病”涉嫌诈骗
北京市律师协会刑事诉讼法专业委员会秘书长刘玲称，胡万林不具备行医资格，没有医学知识，且曾多次因非法行医造成他人死亡，被处以刑罚。
但其隐瞒了这一真相，再次以“神医”面目出现，虚构了医治百病的事实，实施了一系列的欺骗行为，如在网上虚假宣传能够医治百病，鼓动他人参加其授课的培训班，以收“学费”名义谋取财产等。
这些行为，使得受骗者产生错误认识，在不明真相的情况下处分了个人财产，造成财产损失，而胡万林非法占有他人财物的目的得以实现。
根据刑法规定，胡万林以收学费名义骗取学员财物的行为，可能涉嫌诈骗罪。
通过QQ群拉学员属非法
刘玲律师说，开班授课，首先要具有医疗管理部门认证的资质。开班授课前，还需到教育部门申请备案，收费要到工商、税务部门办理登记等。
显然，胡万林不具备相应资质，也没有依照行政法规向有关机关提出相应申请。所以，胡万林开班传授中医治疗方法的行为是非法的。
同时，胡万林2000年因非法行医罪被判处有期徒刑15年，释放时间不详。如本次犯罪发生在其刑罚执行完毕5年内，且也被判处有期徒刑以上刑罚，胡万林则构成累犯，依法应从重处罚。
被害人家属可索民事赔偿
阴建峰教授表示，刑事诉讼法规定，被害人由于被告人的犯罪行为而遭受物质损失的，在刑事诉讼过程中，有权提起附带民事诉讼。被害人死亡的，被害人的近亲属有权提起附带民事诉讼，同时可以申请法院采取保全措施，查封、扣押或者冻结被告人的财产。
本案中，刑事案件已经立案，被害人家属有权提起附带民事诉讼，要求胡万林赔偿其损失。
文/记者汪红实习生梅双
赞