Brothers 132 days in custody after the release by the national compensation 58,000 | falsely accused brother | | award _ news
Danzhou detained 132 days after releasing the two brothers won the national award of more than 58,000 yuan

Original title: Brothers 132 days in custody after the release by the national compensation 58,000

Southern Metropolis daily, March 27 (reporter Lin Shu text/photo), "thanked the province second intermediate court made the right decision, to prove our innocence, also thanked the Danzhou procuratorial organs conscientiously fulfill their legal obligations, a national award was paid to us in a timely manner. "When I get in the State compensation of more than 58,000 yuan, brothers lives in Danzhou Bai Ma Jing Zhen Fu Jinling and Fu Jinyao is very happy, after more than a year to keep the complaint, they use the law to prove his innocence.

　　Moored fishing dispute

On January 5, 2014, around 9 o'clock in the evening, Fu Jinling and Fu Jinyao brothers open fishing boat, Danzhou, baimajing port dock Dock, Wu Fu Jinling fishing boat pushed his boat for the rushed aboard insults Fu Jinling brothers, both by the spat turned into a scuffle. Fu Jinling see my little brother was beaten, picked up the ship's defenses, to Wu's thighs, and drew blood, so both sides stop. Character's brothers and his father immediately sent Wu to baimajing hospitals for treatment, and pay the corresponding expenses, reconciliation between the two parties.

On April 1 of that year, Wu said, scuffled with Fu Jia brother event last time resulting in fractures of his ribs, constitute the secondary injuries, requiring break brothers give huge compensation. Rejected Wu after the alarm. On May 16 of that year, police in Danzhou on suspicion of intentional injury to break the brothers be detained. On June 20 of that year, Danzhou city Procuratorate approved the arrest.

Fu Jinling brothers against this view that body friction between the two sides is not sufficient to cause Wu rib fracture, then said the complaint, when Wu injured popliteal position is on the left leg, but the arrest based on the contents of the judiciary are rib fractures and secondary injuries is obviously false accusation.

On September 9, 2014, provincial police forensic Center of Wu damage for recertification, think Wu 9th rib old fractures form when an event occurs that cannot be identified as January 5, expert opinion: Wu left popliteal fossa damages for minor injuries. 18th, Danzhou prosecutors returned the case to the public security organ for supplementary investigation. 7 days later, on September 25, Danzhou, public security authorities to withdraw the case will break Brothers release. At this point, the character's brothers were arrested detained 132 days.

　　After a complaint by the national compensation

In November of the same year, break brothers apply for national compensation.

On February 3, 2015, Danzhou city prosecutor's Office believes that Fu Jinling injures another minor injury, belonging to the 19th State compensation law (c) exemption under circumstances, no compensation decisions. Character refuses to accept the brothers, to the provincial compensation for seized the second branch applies for reconsideration. Provincial inspection branch of the second to make a decision, maintaining Danzhou prosecutors no compensation decisions.

Break brothers again, and to the provincial compensation Board for compensation in the second decision. Homes in the province, two Compensation Committee believes that, in judicial practice, the crime of intentional injury is intentional grievous bodily harm constitutes a minor result as the standard, if the victim of the damage as minor injuries, just not up to the criminal standard, does not constitute a crime. Therefore, the results do not constitute a crime and the circumstances are obviously minor is not considered a crime must not be confused. 2012 newly-amended State compensation law will arrest the imputation principle of compensation as "liability for results", that is, as long as after the arrest of citizens decided to dismiss the case, no prosecution or acquitted termination liability judgments, fall within the scope of State compensation. From this case view, for Fu Jin makes beat Wu a article of behavior, Danzhou City Public Security Bureau to injury identification views occurred changes, found not should held criminal for by made revoked case of decided, that Danzhou City Public Security Bureau revoked case is to behavior caused of results and not plot as according to of, not belongs to national compensation method 15th article subsection (a) of case, on Fu Jinling and Fu Jinyao by by damage, national should bear compensation responsibility.

In August 2015, the second intermediate Compensation Commission decision, revoked two measuring criminal compensation decision, Danzhou and criminal compensation decisions of the public prosecutor's Office, Attorney compensation, Danzhou city break brothers were violations of liberty national compensation 29003.04 132 days.

Recently, the walk after the break brothers successfully get compensation for this country.

Source: Southern Metropolis daily

Responsible editor: Wang Hao

Article keywords:
Damages for falsely accused brother

I want feedback
Save a Web page
China economic NET

两兄弟被羁押132天后释放 获国家赔偿金5.8万|诬告|兄弟|赔偿金_新闻资讯
儋州两兄弟被羁押132天后释放获得国家赔偿金5.8万余元

　　原标题：两兄弟被羁押132天后释放 获国家赔偿金5.8万

　　南国都市报3月27日讯(记者林书喜文/图)“感谢省二中院作出了正确的判决，证明了我们的清白，也感谢儋州检察机关认真履行法律义务，及时给我们支付了国家赔偿金。”在拿到5.8万余元的国家赔偿金后，家住儋州白马井镇的符金令和符金瑶两兄弟十分高兴，经过一年多的不停申诉，他们用法律证明了自己的清白。

　　停泊渔船引纷争

　　2014年1月5日晚9点左右，符金令和符金瑶兄弟开渔船到儋州市白马井渔港码头靠岸时，吴某条以符金令的渔船挤到了他的船为由，冲上船辱骂符 金令兄弟，双方由口角之争演变为扭打。符金令看到弟弟被殴打，随手拿起船上的工具防卫，划到吴某条的大腿，并流了血，双方因此停手。符氏兄弟及其父亲立即 送吴某条到白马井卫生院进行治疗，并承担了相应的费用，双方和解。

　　同年4月1日，吴某条称，上次跟符家兄弟发生扭打事件造成了自己肋骨骨折，构成二级轻伤，要求符氏兄弟给予巨额赔偿。遭到拒绝后吴某条报警。同年5月16日，儋州警方以涉嫌故意伤害罪对符氏兄弟予以刑事拘留。同年6月20日，被儋州市检察机关批准逮捕。

　　符金令兄弟对此不服，认为当时双方发生的肢体摩擦不足以造成吴某条肋骨骨折，遂提出控诉称，当时吴某条受伤的部位是左腿腘窝，但司法机关批捕的依据内容却是肋骨骨折二级轻伤，明显是诬告。

　　2014年9月9日，省公安司法鉴定中心对吴某条损害程度进行重新鉴定，认为吴某条第9肋骨陈旧性骨折无法认定为1月5日的事件发生时所形成 的，鉴定意见为：吴某条左腘窝损伤为轻微伤。同月18日，儋州检察机关将该案退回公安机关补充侦查。7天后即9月25日，儋州公安机关撤销该案件，将符氏 兄弟释放。至此，符氏兄弟被逮捕羁押了132天。

　　几经申诉终获国家赔偿

　　同年11月，符氏兄弟申请国家赔偿。

　　2015年2月3日，儋州市检察院认为，符金令伤害他人致轻微伤，属于国家赔偿法第十九条第(三)项规定的免责情形，作出不予赔偿的决定。符氏兄弟不服，向省检二分院提出赔偿申请复议。省检二分院作出复议决定，维持儋州检察机关不予赔偿的决定。

　　符氏兄弟再次不服，向省二中院赔偿委员会申请作出赔偿决定。省二中院赔偿委员会认为，在司法实践中，故意伤害罪是以故意伤害他人身体构成轻伤的 结果作为入罪标准，如果受害人的损伤程度为轻微伤，就达不到刑事立案标准，不构成犯罪。因此，结果不构成犯罪与情节显著轻微不认为是犯罪不能混为一谈。 2012年新修正的国家赔偿法将逮捕赔偿的归责原则确定为“结果归责”，即只要对公民采取逮捕措施后，决定撤销案件，不起诉或者判决宣告无罪终止追究刑事 责任的，属于国家赔偿的范围。从本案来看，针对符金令殴打吴某条的行为，儋州市公安局以伤情鉴定意见发生变化，发现不应追究刑事责任为由作出撤销案件的决 定，即儋州市公安局撤销案件是以行为造成的结果而不是情节作为依据的，不属于国家赔偿法第十五条第(一)的情形，对符金令和符金瑶所受损害，国家应当承担 赔偿责任。

　　2015年8月，省二中院赔偿委员会作出决定，撤销省二分检刑事赔偿复议决定和儋州市检察院的刑事赔偿决定，由儋州市检察院赔偿符氏兄弟被侵犯人身自由132天的国家赔偿金各29003.04元。

　　日前，经走完相关程序后，符氏兄弟顺利拿到了这笔国家赔偿金。

　　来源：南国都市报

责任编辑：王浩成

文章关键词：
诬告 兄弟 赔偿金

我要反馈
保存网页
中国经济网