In response to Vice President of Yunnan University papers fabricated data: active withdrawal of Yunnan University | draft | Vice President _ news

Original title: response paper, Vice President of Yunnan University was revoked because of fabricated data events

Kunming, May 9 Reuters new media (Xinhua Yue Yang Jing slowly) recently, "Vice President of Yunnan University in a paper in the journal Cell Reports to the famous cell for more than two months after the report was published, was withdrawn because of data fabrication" message of concern. 9th, Yunnan University in response to Xinhua said, through a third party group of experts involved in the investigation, withdrew draft allegations, first author admitted to tampering with the picture, after errors were found, the Vice-Presidents "have decided to take a withdrawal draft".

7th, media "science now" gives the Vice President of Yunnan University article the paper was withdrawn because of fabricated data, the paper said, "from Yunnan University in a paper published in the prominent journal Cell Reports after nearly three months, was withdrawn because of data fabrication. Revoke statement, the paper said bacteria abundance data were fabricated. All authors agree to withdraw the paper. "This paper is issued by many websites, has fueled the" academic fraud "discussion.

8th, Yunnan University invited the independent investigation team of outside experts, to paper surveys soliciting withdrawal events. Paper entitled intestinal colonization of bacteria through the production of nitric oxide to promote nematodes of innate immunity. Group queries the relevant English sources, challenged the after party, the final investigation results are announced on 9th.

Survey results think, "papers Yu February 16, 2016 published, March 1 by Germany peer Hinrich Schlunburg Professor proposed questions, think the papers Schedule 1 of original data and Figure 1 inconsistent, paper communications author after seriously check found, Figure 1 does exists errors, in find the papers first author Dr graduate Shaw a check Hou, Shaw a admitted in no told other author of situation Xia tampered with has figure 1 of Spore Bacillus of Feng degrees. In author's opinion this is a serious academic problems, Shaw had a serious criticism, and decided on March 2 that the initiative to withdraw draft. March 3 official letters to the editorial department withdraw draft application. With the Editorial Office contacts, on May 3 and March 24 Editorial Board agreed to withdraw draft statement issued to withdraw draft. ”

Press the corresponding author of the paper in a telephone interview Zhang Keqin, Vice President of Yunnan University, Zhang Keqin, told reporters that his party, not voice their opinion on the whole thing, but he also said, "investigation group is fine, I'm sure they will realistically give an authoritative conclusions. "The reporter has learned, Zhang Keqin has written to Yunnan University writing examination.

Reporters interviewed professionals, the "author" and "first author" interpretation of the concept. "Author" is a paper's head, bear the task of writing and checking of requirements, design, papers, Editorial Department is responsible for all communications and accept the readers ' Advisory, and responsible for the reliability of the article. "Author" is the biggest researchers in paper work, is the implementation of the action on the front lines and the collection and processing of the raw data and primary responsibility for authenticity of the research results and data.

Responsible editor: Wang Hao

Article keywords:
Vice President of Yunnan University

I want feedback
Save a Web page
Xinhua

云南大学回应副校长论文捏造数据：主动撤稿|副校长|云南大学_新闻资讯

　　原标题：云南大学回应副校长论文因捏造数据被撤销事件

　　新华社昆明5月9日新媒体专电(记者 岳冉冉 杨静)近日，一则“云南大学副校长的一篇论文在著名期刊Cell Reports《细胞报告》发表两个多月后，因部分数据捏造而被撤销”的消息引起关注。9日，云南大学回应新华社记者称，通过第三方专家组的介入调查，撤稿事件属实，第一作者承认篡改了图片，该名副校长在发现错误后“决定主动撤稿”。

　　7日，自媒体“今日科学”发出《云南大学副校长论文因捏造数据被撤销》一文，该文称，“来自云南大学的一篇论文在著名期刊Cell Reports发表近三个月后，因部分数据捏造而被撤销。撤销声明表示，论文中图一表示细菌丰富度的数据是被捏造的。所有作者同意撤销该论文。”该文发出后被多家网站转载，引起网友对“学术造假”的讨论。

　　8日，云南大学邀请校外有关专家组成独立调查组，对论文撤稿事件进行了调查。论文的题目是《肠道定植细菌通过产生一氧化氮促进线虫天然免疫》。专家组在查询了相关中英文原始资料，质询了相关当事人后，于9日公布了最终调查结果。

　　调查结果认为，“论文于2016年2月16日发表，3月1日经德国同行Hinrich Schlunburg教授提出疑问，认为该论文附表1的原始数据与图1不符，本文通讯作者经过认真核对发现，图1确实存在错误，在找该论文第一作者博士研究生肖某核对后，肖某承认在没有告知其他作者的情况下篡改了图1的芽孢杆菌的丰度。本文通讯作者认为这是一个严重的学术问题，对肖某进行了严肃的批评教育，并于3月2日决定主动撤稿。3月3日正式发信给编辑部提出撤稿申请。经与编辑部多次联系，3月24日编辑部同意撤稿并于5月3日发布撤稿声明。”

　　记者电话采访了该论文的通讯作者云南大学副校长张克勤，张克勤告诉记者，自己是当事人，不便对整个事情发表看法，但他也表示，“调查组的工作很细，我相信他们会实事求是给出一个权威结论。”记者了解到，张克勤已向云南大学写出了书面检查。

　　记者采访了相关业内人士，对“通讯作者”与“第一作者”的概念进行了解读。“通讯作者”是一篇论文的总负责人，承担课题的经费、设计、论文的书写和把关，负责与编辑部的一切通信联系和接受读者的咨询，并对文章的可靠性负责。“第一作者”是论文工作中贡献最大的研究人员，是第一线操作的实施者和原始数据的收集和处理人，对研究结果和数据的真实性负首要责任。

责任编辑：王浩成

文章关键词：
副校长 云南大学

我要反馈
保存网页
新华网