Man charged with murder of Heilongjiang province has washed out grievances after 4 years but difficult to get State compensation | | torture _ of national compensation news

In 2011, Chen Ruiwu ended his decade of detention time, their murder charges have also been washed away. But in an application for State compensation were filed after 4 years, Langfang intermediate people's Court will still not give Chen Ruiwu final compensation results. For reasons, Langfang City Intermediate Court did not respond.

In 2000, bazhou city shengfang town, three of Liu Decheng brutally ended. From 2001 to 2007, Chen Ruiwu 4 people wrongly convicted of murder three times. In 2011, Langfang, Hebei province High Court completely overturn its decisions, such as Chen Ruiwu 4 acquittals.

State compensation for delay in getting Chen Ruiwu inability to close the smoke

　　Trial: hand-cranked telephone electric shocks to extract confessions

Chen Ruiwu memories around December 25, 2000, Heilongjiang Hulan County in his hometown, his dog barking collective. Chen Ruiwu thought it was outside stealing dogs, with iron bars to open the door. He saw shadow wanted to take an iron rod at the door, only to find that there are two gun to his own head. Four or five police officers in civilian clothing outside the door, opened the black car without police. Chen Ruiwu obtained at that time, was taken to the local police station by the police. At this time, he knew he was in Langfang police. That night, Chen Ruiwu bazhou city, was taken to the Criminal Investigation Brigade.

Street first before Chen Ruiwu (micro signal: qianjieyihao) said that the Criminal Investigation Brigade, the police asked if he participated in the December 22 in bazhou city shengfang town, murder. This murder, shengfang town, Sheng Tang Lu Liu Decheng was killed. Among them, the wife Wang Junling, son of liugen in 22nd around 4 o'clock in the morning is the rope strangling. Her husband Liu Decheng 22nd at 5 o'clock in the afternoon at home was hit in the head with a blunt dead. Police told him that his brother-in-law Wei Chunjiang confessions in August 2000, Liu Decheng Chen Duanwu plotted robbery.

Chen Ruiwu himself did not know Liu Decheng, a death, he did not participate in the killings. However, the police did not recognize his claim. Chen Ruiwu said police in order to obtain his confession, his confession. Main method is that old-fashioned hand-cranked telephone wire wrapped around their own parts by hand phone power, shocks himself with a phone line. Sometimes tapping his patella with a blunt, or iron file repeatedly scraped his ribs. The Criminal Investigation Brigade interrogators also replaced, asked Chen Ruiwu describe after trial, the heart and the head does not apply. Police involved in the interrogation later told Chen Ruiwu, these symptoms can be life accident once he was found evidence of sudden death in the cause of death was a heart attack, cerebral hemorrhage.

Despite the torture, Chen Ruiwu guilty confession has not. However, because the cases were tried together with 4 other people, 3 people have made a confession of guilt. The four men and their families are moving forward: first (micro signal: qianjieyihao) reporters reflect, torture of the detainee suffered the modus operandi were similar.

　　Verdict: tax Dan Cheng, at least the key evidence

Guilty confessions 3 in 2002, although the first trial when a confession in court, and police did not have the killer material evidence such as fingerprints, DNA, but still by the Langfang intermediate people's Court identified as Liu Decheng Chen Ruiwu and others directly involved in the case.

Langfang intermediate people's Court in its judgement finds that because the suspect Wang Xiaomin suspect, and his own PIN Wang Junling Wang Yuzhen and victim of an improper sexual relationship, resentment, demanding ex-lover Shang Zhihong murder. Shang Zhihong contact the brother-in-law, yuanweidong, yuanweidong and contact fellow Chen Ruiwu, shengfang town, and locals Yang Hongyi formed the killings "Planning Group". On December 22 when committing, Yang Hongyi Lookout, yuanweidong and Chen Ruiwu into Liu Decheng, Wang Junling was strangled with a rope and liugen, Liu Decheng and reservoir home. A little after 5 o'clock in the afternoon, Liu Decheng returned home from work, and blows to the head by yuanweidong grate, Chen Ruiwu carry knife pierced in the neck died. Chen Ruiwu all five people commit murder, sentenced to death and deprived of political rights for life.

Extorting Chen Ruiwu left leg injury

After Chen Ruiwu appeal, Hebei province High Court found no sufficient evidence and remand Court reheard in Langfang city. In the absence of any evidence of the case, in Langfang city hospital in 2004 of the second sentence is changed. Shang Zhihong murder motives become blurred, Wang Xiaomin committed intentional homicide was identified as facts are not clear that the evidence is insufficient, a judgment of acquittal is released. Court finds Shang Zhihong was entrusted to be hired, what was asked who was not identified. Yang Hongyi was just watch, without actual participation in killing, commuted to life imprisonment, deprived of political rights for life. Shang Zhihong because just hired, not directly involved in the killing and sentenced to death, suspended for two years, deprived of political rights for life.

Chen Ruiwu, who after the second appeal, Hebei province High Court to send the case back for retrial again. Langfang City Intermediate Court for the third time decision has maintained the original judgement. However, Chen Ruiwu, who still choose to appeal.

Street first before (micro signal: qianjieyihao) reporter learned from Chen Ruiwu, Chen Ruiwu so insisted that he did not kill, territory of Langfang city, because at the time he did not, but in his hometown of Heilongjiang province. When he was with the yuanweidong home to pay agricultural tax. He would tell police during interrogation. But the public prosecutor's Office and the Court believed that Chen Ruiwu, who described their hometowns to pay agricultural taxes precisely reflects the modus operandi of the plot of "cunning".

Three decisions in Langfang are found, yuanweidong and Chen Duanwu is to their country of origin to make the agricultural tax in the name of shengfang town, pretending to leave, make no illusion of time of crime. In fact, they went to Tianjin and shengfang town, just leave town and other places in the Hall b, on the night before the crime was committed and back into investment.

Before the first hearing in the case, Chen Ruiwu father went to the police and court evidence. When yuanweidong in the village to pay agricultural taxes, accounting in the village gave him a sheet of stamps. Tax receipt date is on the case on December 22. But police got the invoice accounting statements. Accounting for said invoice the actual date is December 24, appears is 22nd, is yuanweidong ask her to change. Courts therefore did not adopt tax receipt as evidence favorable to Chen Duanwu.

After the verdict, Jia Lei Chen Duanwu lawyer visits to the home of Chen Duanwu, found a village stub accounting invoicing. This careful accounting of each stub, part two, two numbers are consecutive, with no missing. Bigger than the original Weidong tax receipt stub numbers of stubs, the payment dates are shown on December 22. Jia Lei believes that this can prove that the false testimony of the village accountant, tax receipts are signed by the 22nd. He takes it again as a key piece of evidence presented to the Tribunal.

Hebei province people's High Court after seeing this evidence be accepted, and there is no continued remand, but on November 12, 2009, the Court of Final Appeal judgment. Hebei province High Court believes that killing Liu Decheng Chen Duanwu and others an original judgment of the facts are not clear, insufficient evidence, not found. Chen Duanwu, Shang Zhihong, Yang Hongyi acquitted release. Yuanweidong also involved in the other case, have not been released.

On November 4, 2011, bazhou Chen Duanwu is pretrial detention centres officially released.

Chen Ruiwu holding a certificate of release

　　State compensation filing 4 years ' results

Street first before (micro signal: qianjieyihao) reporter learned that, after less than three years Chen Duanwu, healthy father dies. In order to avenge her husband, Chen Duanwu wife running around, too busy to take care of her daughter. Chen Duanwu daughter Chen Ying in the five grade drop out. Chen Ying said another main reason for dropping out is, the father of "murderers" status for its great pressure on schools, students and teachers, all differently. Said Chen Duanwu, 32 years old when he was detained, was released 42 years old, my best Decade was delayed in the detention center, he has reason to require, for national compensation to wrongly convicted.

Chen Ruiwu scavenger

As early as the end of 2011, Chen Duanwu, who the State compensation application is handed over to the Langfang Municipal Intermediate Court and won the case in year. However, the results of compensation but nothing below.

Said Chen Duanwu, was delayed by the Court will determine the amount of compensation, because yuanweidong is involved in other cases there is no clear, the Court does not want to batch to treat men who handle State compensation issues. Therefore, they want to yuanweidong another case with a clear conclusion, United State compensation to them. Chen Duanwu is confirmed by Jia Lei.

Langfang city, hospital staff said, the Court does have application for State compensation for Chen Duanwu, who filed, there was no result. No specific reason unclear results, may be the cases still pending.

Chen Ruiwu demonstrates itself in how the criminal investigation brigade are extorting a confession by torture

Yushi Beijing lawyer Jiang Jian said, the cases of State compensation, the claimant has been finally confirmed to be innocent, previously held for the crime that has been overturned, then, the organ under compensatory obligations therefore errors caused by the exercise of authority claim lawful damages shall bear liability. Organ under compensatory obligations to one crime suspects there might be other protracted compensation is clearly inappropriate.

First, the claimant was a crime because they were overthrown and imprisoned, was not detained in connection with another case, as to how the results of another case, not associated with the claimant to apply for State compensation. Secondly, the organ under compensatory obligations in excess of the statutory compensation periods have not decided, for the reasons stated, is not subject to statutory subject matter. Finally, this is State compensation law guarantee the right of citizens to make the State the right to compensation, the organ under compensatory obligations shall promptly comply with compensation obligations are against the spirit of.

Jiang Jian said that China's State compensation law stipulates, the organ under compensatory obligations shall, within two months from the date of receipt of the application, make a decision on whether compensation. Organ under compensatory obligations are the people's courts, whether compensation is not within the time stipulated in the decision, to which the claimant may, in accordance with the provisions of this article apply to the people's Court at the UNCC compensation decisions.

Author/Sir phantom edit/small

Responsible editor: Mao Minmin SN184

Article keywords:
State compensation of torture

I want feedback
Save a Web page
Front Street, first

黑龙江男子被控杀人，洗清冤屈4年后却难获得国家赔偿 |国家赔偿|刑讯逼供_新闻资讯

　　2011年，陈瑞武结束了自己十年的看守所岁月，自己的杀人罪名也得到洗刷。但至今，在申请国家赔偿获立案4年多后，廊坊市中级人民法院仍然未给陈瑞武最终的赔偿结果。对于原因，廊坊市中院未作回应。

　　2000年，霸州市胜芳镇刘德成一家三口惨遭灭门。2001年至2007年，陈瑞武等4人三次被错判杀人。2011年，河北省高院彻底推翻廊坊中院的判决，陈瑞武等4人无罪释放。

迟迟未拿到国家补偿的陈瑞武在无力抽闷烟

　　审讯：手摇电话电击逼供

　　陈瑞武回忆，2000年12月25日左右，在自己的黑龙江呼兰县老家，自己养的狗突然集体狂吠。陈瑞武以为是门外有人偷狗，带着铁棍打开门。他 见到门口有黑影就想拿铁棍打，却发现有两支手枪指着自己的头。门外的四五名警察身穿便衣，开的黑色轿车没有警标。陈瑞武当时就蒙了，被警察带到了当地派出 所。这时，他才知道抓自己的是廊坊的警察。当天夜里，陈瑞武就被带往霸州市刑侦大队。

　　陈瑞武对前街一号（微信号：qianjieyihao）记者说，在刑侦大队，民警问他是否参与了12月22日在霸州市胜芳镇的一起凶杀案。在这 起凶杀案中，胜芳镇胜堂路的刘德成一家被杀。其中，妻子王俊玲、儿子刘根在22日凌晨4点左右被绳索勒死。丈夫刘德成于22日下午5点多，在家中被人用钝 器猛击头部死亡。民警告诉他，他的小舅子魏春江供述，2000年8月间，陈端武就密谋过抢劫刘德成一家。

　　陈瑞武表示，自己对刘德成一家的死并不知情，自己更没有参与杀人。但是，警方并未认可他的的说法。陈瑞武说，警方为了获得自己的认罪口供，对自 己刑讯逼供。主要方法是，用老式手摇电话机的线缠绕在自己的各个部位，通过手摇电话发电，用电话线电击自己。有的时候，还用钝器敲击自己的髌骨，或者用铁 锉反复刮自己的肋骨。刑侦大队还更换审讯人员，要求陈瑞武描述一下被审讯后，心脏和头部是否有不适。参与讯问的民警事后告诉陈瑞武，这些不适症状可以作为 一旦他发生生命意外，被认定死因是心脏病猝死、脑出血的证据。

　　虽然遭受了刑讯逼供，陈瑞武始终未做出有罪供述。但是，因为同一起案件被审讯的其他4人中，有3人做出了有罪供述。这四个人及其家属均向前街一号（微信号：qianjieyihao）记者反映，受审者均遭受了手法相似的刑讯逼供。

　　判决：缴税单成翻案关键证据

　　虽然做出有罪供述的3人在2002年的第一次庭审时均当庭翻供，且警方没有掌握凶手指纹、DNA等关键性证据，但是陈瑞武等人仍然被廊坊市中级人民法院认定为刘德成案的直接参与者。

　　廊坊市中级人民法院在判决书中认定，因为嫌疑人王晓敏怀疑，和自己姘靠的王玉振与被害人王俊玲有不正当性关系，因此心生怨恨，要求前恋人尚志红 雇凶杀人。尚志红就联系了连襟原伟东，原伟东又联系了同乡陈瑞武，和胜芳镇本地人杨洪义组成了杀人“谋划小组”。12月22日凌晨作案时，杨洪义在外望 风，原伟东和陈瑞武潜入刘德成家，用绳子勒死了王俊玲和刘根，并一直藏在刘德成家中。下午5点多，刘德成下班回家后，又被原伟东用炉条打击头部，被陈瑞武 随身携带的尖刀扎中颈部死亡。陈瑞武等五人全部犯故意杀人罪，判处死刑，剥夺政治权利终身。

刑讯逼供给陈瑞武腿部留下的伤害

　　陈瑞武等人上诉后，河北省高院认为案件证据不足，发回廊坊市中院重审。在没有增加任何证据的情况下，廊坊市中院2004年的第二次判决却出现了 变化。尚志红雇凶杀人的动机变得模糊不清，王晓敏犯故意杀人罪被认定为事实不清，证据不足，改判无罪释放。法院只认定尚志红是受人之托雇凶，究竟是谁人所 托却未查清。杨洪义因为只是望风，没有实际参与杀人，改判为无期徒刑，剥夺政治权利终身。尚志红因为只是雇凶，没有直接参与杀人过程，判处死刑，缓期两年 执行，剥夺政治权利终身。

　　陈瑞武等人二次上诉后，河北省高院再次将案件发回重审。廊坊市中院的第三次判决基本维持了原判。但是，陈瑞武等人依然选择上诉。

　　前街一号（微信号：qianjieyihao）记者从陈瑞武处了解到，陈瑞武之所以如此坚持自己没有杀人，是因为案发当时自己根本不在廊坊市境 内，而是在黑龙江老家。当时他是陪原伟东回乡缴纳农业税。他在审讯期间就把实情告诉了警方。但是检察院和法院却认为，陈瑞武等人叙述的回乡缴纳农业税的情 节恰恰反映了他们作案的“狡猾”。

　　三份廊坊中院做出的判决均认定，原伟东和陈端武是以回原籍交农业税为名，佯装离开胜芳镇，制造没有作案时间的假象。实际上，他们只是离开胜芳镇去了天津、堂二里镇等地，于案发前一晚又潜回胜芳镇。

　　在此案第一次审理之前，陈瑞武的父亲就向警方和法院提交了一项证据。原伟东在村里缴纳农业税的时候，村里的会计给他开了一张税票。税票上的日期 恰恰就是案发日12月22日。但是警方却拿到了开票会计的口供。会计供称，开票的实际日期是12月24日，之所以显示是22日，是原伟东要求她改的。法院 因此没有采纳税票作为对陈端武有利的证据。

　　一审判决以后，陈端武的代理律师贾磊到陈端武的家乡实地探访，找到了村会计开票的存根。这名仔细的会计在每张存根上编了两次号，两次号都是连续 的，中间没有缺失。而比原伟东税票存根编号大一些的存根，显示的缴纳日期都是在12月22日。贾磊认为，这就能够证明，村会计的证词不实，税票确实是22 日签字的。他将这作为关键证据再次呈送法庭。

　　河北省高级人民法院见到这份证据以后予以采纳，且没有继续发回重审，而是在2009年11月12日作出终审判决。河北省高院认为，陈端武等人杀害刘德成一家的原判决事实不清，证据不足，不予认定。陈端武、尚志红、杨洪义无罪释放。原伟东还牵涉其他案件，没有被释放。

　　2011年11月4日，陈端武被霸州市看守所正式释放。

陈瑞武手举释放证明书

　　国家赔偿立案4年无结果

　　前街一号（微信号：qianjieyihao）记者了解到，陈端武被关押后不到三年，原本健康的父亲就郁郁而终。为了给丈夫伸冤，陈端武的妻子 四处奔走，无暇照顾女儿。陈端武的女儿陈颖小学五年级就辍学了。陈颖说，辍学的另一个主要原因是，父亲的“杀人犯”身份给自己在学校造成了很大的压力，同 学和老师都对自己另眼相待。陈端武说，他被关押的时候32岁，被释放的时候42岁，人生最好的十年被耽误在了看守所里，他有理由也有需要，因为错判得到国 家的赔偿。

陈瑞武曾拾荒为生

　　早在2011年年底，陈端武等人的国家赔偿申请就递交给了廊坊市中院，并于当年获得了立案。但是，赔偿结果却迟迟没有下文。

　　陈端武说，法院之所以迟迟不愿意确定赔偿金额，是因为原伟东牵涉的其他案件目前还没有审理清楚，法院不愿意分批给同案的蒙冤者处理国家赔偿事宜。因此，他们希望原伟东的另一个案件有了明确结论之后，再统一给他们进行国家赔偿。陈端武的说法得到了贾磊的证实。

　　廊坊市中院的工作人员称，法院确实已经对陈端武等人的国家赔偿申请立案，目前还没有结果。没有结果的具体原因不清楚，可能是案件还在审理中。

陈瑞武演示自己在刑侦大队如何受到刑讯逼供

　　北京雄志律师事务所姜健律师说，本起国家赔偿案件中，赔偿请求人已经被最终确认无罪，原先关押其的犯罪事实已被推翻，那么，赔偿义务机关因此错 误行使职权而造成赔偿请求人合法权益遭到损害的，应当承担赔偿责任。现赔偿义务机关以其中之一的犯罪嫌疑人可能涉及其他犯罪而对赔偿申请久拖不决，显然是 不恰当的。

　　首先，赔偿请求人是因已被推翻的罪行而关押的，并非是因另一起案件而关押的，至于另一起案件结果如何，与赔偿请求人申请国家赔偿没有关联性。其 次，赔偿义务机关超过法定期限未作出赔偿决定，所陈述的理由，并不属于法定事由。最后，这也是与国家赔偿法保障公民享有依法取得国家赔偿的权利，赔偿义务 机关应当及时履行赔偿义务的精神内涵相违背。

　　姜健说，我国国家赔偿法规定，赔偿义务机关应当自收到申请之日起两个月内，作出是否赔偿的决定。赔偿义务机关是人民法院的，未在规定期限内作出是否赔偿的决定，赔偿请求人可以依照本条规定向其上一级人民法院赔偿委员会申请作出赔偿决定。

　　作者 /幽灵爵士 编辑 / 小汤圆

责任编辑：茅敏敏 SN184

文章关键词：
国家赔偿 刑讯逼供

我要反馈
保存网页
前街一号