"Chinese trainers fight 32 Japanese planes" |-Japanese video red herring | warplanes _ news
①
②
③
"My students were killed, now it's my teacher. ”
This sentence ever touched you?
However experts access to relevant archives, many details in the story does not match historical
In recent days, a video of the air war of resistance against Japan, and max out your circle of friends. Video shows on May 28, 1940, an air force instructor driving trainer alone, Chengdu fleet of 32 aircraft, rushed into the bombing, finally safe to return home in machine gun fire ... ... Saw this was spoil by blood video, Internet users and all the "air Zhao zilong" case.
However, according to the Chengdu municipal archives to check on May 28, 1940, has no record of the bombing, while surviving 98 defense veterans also said that at that time not yet heard of something so exciting.
Red
Japan writers found video
Instructor words touched many people
Famous war expert, travel writer Denis Sassou-Nguesso did not expect, Beijing Youth channels aired a video of the war last year, suddenly lit up the Internet in recent days. As a video Narrator of the story, he is pushed to the forefront.
In the video, Denis Sassou-Nguesso said his Japan visits the war information, accidentally received this video. Video by two Japan journalist koyanagi and Yagi shot, tells the story of May 28, 1940, the Japanese deployed 32 aircraft bombed in Chengdu. Because the Chinese air force's combat aircraft have all been (Nikki) knocked out, the Japanese thought that the bombing would not be any resistance. However, the machine flew over in Chengdu on the day, a Chinese plane suddenly rushed into the Japanese fleet, "the Chinese aircraft to Japan of aircraft parts, played the blown sky high, but I couldn't get down, because his plane was too small. ”
Screen, Denis Sassou-Nguesso continued to explain, saying the plane during the day under siege, and eventually killed. Meanwhile, Denis Sassou-Nguesso, also found the pilot was surnamed Li's instructors, and this aircraft in Chengdu China Central flight training aircraft of the air force.
But the most moving, is instructor in the diary of the day leaving Lee's words, "my students were killed, now it's my teacher. ”
With this year's "9·3" victory day comes, the video attracted the attention of many people. Touched the sky hero, writer Denis Sassou-Nguesso, praise, but there are experts and scholars on its authenticity in doubt.
In doubt
Of doubt:
On May 28, 1940, the Japanese bombing of Chengdu?
Chengdu municipal archives: check on the day bombing records
"On May 28, 1940, no recorded Japanese bombs, Chengdu. "August 29, Ji Yong, a researcher at the Chengdu city archives tell this huaxi City newspaper reporter, he seen this video a long time ago," read, I wonder what his Denis Sassou-Nguesso. ”
Through the national Government statistics on air strikes, Ji Yong found on May 28 and 32 air raids over Chengdu. "During the war, statistics from Chengdu suffered air raid in May 1940, bombed twice. "Ji Yong said from Chengdu Chengdu air tables can be saved in the archives as you can see, on May 18, 19th aircraft hit records, but not in any records on May 28.
Ji Yong said that if an 32 aircraft strikes, will appear on the record, "so many days to bomb didn't record it was suspicious. ”
Doubt II: air force fall
In May 1940, the Chinese air force has no air?
98 defense Veterans: Chengdu aircraft
Mentioned in the video, when the Chinese air force has no combat aircraft. This one, also gave rise to many familiar with the history of the war, in particular experts question the history of air war of resistance against Japan: 1940 China sky, how could not own aircraft?
In this regard, Ji Yong said, not to mention the 1940 until 1941, the Chinese air force in the war against Japan. And that period of time, there are a lot of Soviet aid to China air forces fighting the Japanese in Chengdu.
August 29, at 7 o'clock in the evening, a reporter in wenjiang, Sichuan province, to interview former aerospace defense command monitored deputy leader Liu Jingshi. Is 98 years old, he is still thinking clearly. Chinese Air Force fighter-free for that period, he said it is simply impossible.
"The end of 1940, before I leave, huangtianba, Taiping Temple airport has aircraft. "Said Liu Jingshi, but Chengdu aircraft has been very" valuable ", bombed by the Japanese, taking an evasive tactics," take several losses, saves power, aircraft are generally scattered hidden. ”
Meanwhile, instructor Lee alone into the Japanese fleet, and said he had never heard of, "then, to really have it, will certainly spread, this can greatly raise the morale of the troops. ”
Doubt III: single-blade
Instructor Lee flew alone against the 32 Japanese planes?
Video sources found there were 13 aircraft acting
Micro letter public, "Mongo" also published an article questioning the authenticity of the video.
"Mongo" found video source--by NHK (Japan Broadcasting Association) shot play, Japan News record on July 24. News Notes: Chiang Kai-shek to escape Japanese bombing of Chongqing, fled to Chengdu, the Japanese then launched airstrikes on July 24 in Chengdu. Fly to Chengdu over the encounter against the Chinese air force.
"Mongo" says video not only tells the time problem, and through the investigation, probably is not a Chinese aircraft in the air combat "single party".
His book, check out the battle of the war, found the day General Manager Zou Gengxu led 13 aircraft engaged and finally 6 aircraft damaged, shot down a bomber by the Japanese.
Chengdu municipal archives, queries for "7·24 bomb" records, data, and 36 frames, bomb, 128 and 93 injured, death of 82 people, 628 housing losses.
In response to
Writer Denis Sassou-Nguesso: restore or meet the historical fallacy
Earlier, the writer Denis Sassou-Nguesso said in an interview with journalists on the cover, after discovering the video, he was commissioned by Taiwan's friends find instructor Li's descendants, in the diary of instructor Lee July 24, 1940, found this sentence: my students are killed, now it's my teacher.
However, compared to the existing list of air combat pilot of the day July 24, combatants and non-instructor Li.
"In search of the war history on the road, often difficult, sometimes flawed and regret, but this indomitable spirit, make us unable to extricate themselves. "For the Chinese pilot who fought bravely, Sassou-Nguesso said:" whoever you are, we know that you are our father, give us your blood heritage, struggling to move forward. Thank you, forging a nation's body, leaving us with an unyielding spirit. "Huaxi City newspaper reporter Yang Li, Chengdu city archives images
Responsible editor: Sun Ailin SN146
Article keywords:Fighter's anti-Japanese
I want feedback
Save a Web page
Sichuan online-huaxi City newspaper
“中国教练机独战32架日机”视频真实性存疑|战机|抗日_新闻资讯
①
②
③
“我的学生都战死了，现在该我这个老师上去了。”
这句话是否曾深深打动你？
然而专家查阅相关档案，认为故事中的诸多细节与史料不符
连日来，一段抗日空战的视频，刷爆朋友圈。视频显示，1940年5月28日，一位空军教官独自驾驶着教练机，冲进轰炸成都的32架日机群，最终在机枪扫射中安全返航……看了这段令人血脉偾张的视频，网友们无不为这位“空中赵子龙”点赞。
然而，根据成都市档案馆查证，1940年5月28日无该轰炸记录，同时健在的98岁防空老兵也表示，当时未曾听说有如此振奋人心之事。
走红
旅日作家发现视频
教官一句话感动无数国人
著名抗战史研究专家、旅日作家萨苏没有想到，去年北京青年频道播出的一则抗战视频，近日突然又在网络上火了起来。作为视频故事的讲述者，他也被推向了风口浪尖。
视频中，萨苏称，他在日本访查抗战资料时，一次偶然机会收到这个视频。视频由两名日本记者小柳和八木拍摄，讲述的是1940年5月28日，日军派出32 架飞机轰炸成都。由于当时中国空军的作战飞机已经全部被（日机）打掉了，日军以为这次轰炸不会遭到任何抵抗。然而，当日机飞临成都上空时，一架中国飞机突然冲进日军机群，“这架中国飞机把日本飞机零件，都打得崩到天上去了，但是打不下来，原因是他的飞机太小。”
画面中，萨苏继续讲解，称这架飞机在日机围攻下，最终杀了出去。同时，萨苏还查到这位飞行员是一名姓李的教官，且这架飞机是成都的中国空军中央航校教练机。
而最打动人的，是李教官在当天的日记里留下的一句话，“我的学生都战死了，现在该我这个老师上去了。”
随着今年“9·3”胜利纪念日到来，这则视频引起了不少人的关注。有感慨这位长空英雄的，有为作家萨苏点赞的，但也有专家学者对其真实性存疑的。
存疑
疑点一：事发时间
1940年5月28日，日机轰炸成都？
成都市档案馆：查当日无日机轰炸记录
“1940年5月28日，没有资料记载日机轰炸成都。”8月29日，成都市档案馆研究员姬勇告诉华西都市报记者，很早之前他便看过该视频，“看完了，我对萨苏的讲解存在疑惑。”
通过翻阅国民政府当时关于空袭统计，姬勇没有发现5月28日有32架日机空袭过成都。“从抗战期间，成都遭遇的空袭统计来看，1940年5月确有两次轰 炸。”姬勇说，从成都市档案馆中保存的成都市空袭统计表可以看到，当年5月18日、19日有敌机来袭的记录，但在5月28日则没有任何记载。
姬勇说，若一次有32架飞机来袭，在档案记载上一定会出现，“那么多日机来轰炸居然没记录，这点很可疑。”
疑点二：空军覆灭
1940年5月，中国空军已没飞机？
98岁防空老兵：当时成都仍有飞机
视频中提到，当时中国空军已没了作战飞机。此话一出，也引起不少熟悉抗战历史，特别是抗日空战史专家的疑问：1940年中国天空上，怎么可能没了自己的飞机？
对此，姬勇说，不要说1940年，直到1941年，都有中国空军在对日作战。而且那段时间，还有不少的苏联援华空军在成都对日作战。
8月29日晚7点，记者在温江采访到原四川省防空司令部监视队副队长刘景轼。已是98岁高龄的他，仍然是思维清晰。针对那一时段中国空军无战机的说法，他说根本不可能。
“1940年年底，我离开成都前，黄田坝、太平寺机场都有飞机。”刘景轼说，但在成都的中国飞机已经非常“宝贵”，对于日军前来轰炸，一般采取躲避的策略，“吃过几次亏，得保存力量，飞机一般都是分散隐蔽起来。”
同时，对于李教官独自杀入日军机群的事，他称从未听说过，“那个时期，要真有这事儿，肯定会传开的，这可以很大地振奋军心。”
疑点三：单刀赴会
李教官驾机，独自迎战32架日机？
视频来源找到当时有13架飞机迎击
微信公众号“蒙哥”也发表文章，对视频的真实性表示质疑。
“蒙哥”找到了视频来源——由当时NHK（日本放送协会）拍摄播放，日本新闻里记录这是7月24日发生的。新闻里写道：蒋介石为躲避日军对重庆的轰炸，逃至成都，日军遂在7月24日于成都发动空袭。飞至成都上空时，遇到前来迎战的中国空军。
“蒙哥”说，视频不仅是讲述的时间存在问题，而且通过资料查证，很可能此次空战不是一架中国飞机在“单刀赴会”。
他查阅《抗日战争正面战场》一书，发现当天总领队邹赓续曾带领13架飞机迎战，最终6架飞机受损，击落日军一架轰炸机。
而查询成都市档案馆针对“7·24轰炸”的记载，数据为，日机出动36架，投弹128枚，伤93人，亡82人，房屋损失628间。
回应
作家萨苏：还原历史或遇谬误
此前，作家萨苏在接受封面新闻记者采访时说，发现这段视频后，他曾委托台湾的朋友找到李姓教官的后人，在李教官1940年7月24日的日记里，发现这么一句话：我的学生都战死了，现在该我这个老师上去了。
不过，对比现存的7月24日空战当天中方飞行员的名单，参战人员中并无李姓教官。
“在寻找这场战争历史的道路上，经常会有坎坷，也时而会出现谬误和遗憾，但这种中国人坚忍不拔的精神，使我们不能自拔。”对于这名英勇作战的中国飞行 员，萨苏说：“不管你是谁，我们知道，你都是我们的父兄，把你的血脉传承给我们，奋力向前。感谢你，锻打了一个民族的躯体，留给我们一个不屈的灵魂。”华 西都市报记者杨力成都市档案馆供图
责任编辑：孙爱林 SN146
文章关键词： 战机 抗日
我要反馈
保存网页
四川在线-华西都市报