Shandong Court 7 years owed Hotel 24,000 meals | Court | meal | ledger _ news
7, 24000, which is public in Jinan Cao Juan (not his real name) hanging on the lips of two numbers.
Cao Juan is the owner of the hotel in Changqing district of Jinan City, from 2009 to 2013, the Jinan Changqing district people's court staff to carry out three divisions, with "working lunch" name, open a restaurant four years amounted to Cao Juan up to 300 times, totaling more than 24000, all use "sign" form. Since August 2013, for the recovery of these meals, between Cao Juan many times to and from the hotel and the courts, but often run into a wall.
On December 6, the Jinan Changqing district people's Court told reporters by a staff member of the Office, which involved staff "individuals". While Cao Juan said in the media after the intervention, Changqing District Court has sent staff members to settle the arrears in cash.
> ▲ Hotels show that staff members of the Court, "IOU", displays the frequency and amount of eating. Photograph of qilu evening news network
Restaurant owners: Court staff group dinner
Cao Juan Hotel is located in Changqing district of Jinan University Road, South side of Changqing district people's Court.
This is the 10th year Cao Juan in cooking. Early in 2006, opening a restaurant near her in Changqing district people's Court, also contracted in the middle school cafeteria.
Cao Juan told reporters that because of geographic proximity, and court staff to come to dinner from time to time, they have got, she was familiar with it, which include the implementation of three chambers of a judge surnamed Wang. In February 2009, several staff in the store, talking about dining out topic, these judges recommended to Cao Juan along with Wang, her small restaurants in the future as a "canteen", fixing meals, meals directly to sign the Bill, "final settlement".
Cao Juan in the small business view, such a proposal is tantamount to a "undated". Cao Juan introduced himself with these court officials usually meet and the other is "people Court", stable and was near. In order to be able to do this deal, although there is no talk about specific methods of payment, Cao Juan still has mouth full of promise.
Since then, in Changqing District Court staff, constantly organize tours to dinner. Cao Juan memories, these "Court man" eating level is not high, or regular meals. Every meal is finished, these accounts will be make a note, and then accumulated.
Cao Juan did not expect, a bunch of numbers on the books, trying to "liquidate" take 7 years.
> ▲ On December 6, the restaurant owners use mobile phones from "ious" pictures. The Beijing News reporter Wang Yu photography
Less meals closed court said was "personal behavior"
Reporters received a handwritten IOU displayed, in Changqing District Court to "hold the divisions on the implementation of Credit Union case meals" in the name, from 2009 to 2011 and December, Cao Juan restaurant amounted to 173, cost 12440; 91 2012 annual meal cost is 7238; early 2013 to July 2013, that figure reached 36, a total of 4400 Yuan.
IOU bottom marked with "Executive divisions", and accompanied by two signatures. Cao Juan says, both for the implementation of three judges, one of them is above the King last name judges.
Follow the information on the ious, in four years, Changqing District Court's total staff in the Cao Juan restaurant 300 times total 24078, no checkout.
Who exactly are these money consumption, why keep "ledger" State? in a media interview, Wang, the judge said above, meals of "leadership", the unified arrangements, unified settlement ", reason for arrears, unwilling to talk about it.
Reporters contacted by officers involved in Jinan Changqing district people's Court. A staff member of the Office of the hospital said Cao Juan ious held by the case. On the part of the fees, said the staff member "personal behavior" will be investigated. For Wang, the judge said the "leadership" about the staff not to comment.
The Court "owes some $20,000 meals for 7 years" issue raised public attention quickly. The afternoon of December 6, Cao Juan told reporters, claiming to have been "Changqing court staff" who carry cash to the store, arrears paid.
> (Comics/Gou 犇 original from December 6, 2016 Beijing News)
Dialog
"Going back to the meal, the indictment has written the"
7 years, multiple round trips between the Court and the hotel, in order to recover debts running. The afternoon of December 6, contacted concerned restaurant owners Cao Juan. Cao Juan said, had agreed to "credit card" is that is a regular unit of the Court does not owe money, but didn't think the recovery meal is so difficult.
Reporter: why would agree with "credit card"?
Cao Juan: they (the Court people) used to come here for dinner, talk, very well. So when they came, agreed.
Reporter: what in the name of the store to eat?
Cao Juan: which means meals, as if to say to the law, sometimes need to eat out. My side away from the Court, to come here, or dinning room!
Reporter: what do generally eat?
Cao Juan: eat very common, two or three dozens of money standard. How some people, can eat more than 100 more, don't drink, eat and go, then my account.
Reporter: remember when account in whose name?
Cao Juan: written in the name of Judge Wang often come to a working lunch, sometimes hanging in the name of another of his colleagues.
Reporter: when was the first yaozhang?
Cao Juan: I don't remember exactly, should be the end of 2009. I forget xiazhang, already owes thousands of, just want to open account.
Reporter: yaozhang going on?
Cao Juan: I found that Wang, then he's welcome, let me ask. Then ask finished say, cannot for the time being, let me wait.
Reporter: and have been waiting for?
Cao Juan: I feel that is a regular unit of the Court does not owe money. Later, they come back, I was entertained. Also called the money thing, always made me wait over there.
Reporter: in the name of what?
Cao Juan: is said to lead.
Reporter: this debt have any effect on your life?
Cao Juan: I are owners of small businesses, more than 20,000 dollars is not a small sum, dragged on for so long, has an impact on hotel management. Moreover, the restaurant difficult to do now, was trying to get the money back.
Reporter: ever wondered what method?
Cao Juan: with less money, I don't, but the money a lot. In October, I was ready to find lawyers to prosecute, going back to the meal, the indictment has written the.
Reporter: then solve it?
Cao Juan: this was reported by the media, people come to my shop, and that Wang did not come. They used cash, paid more than 20,000 yuan.
Reporter: what about 7 years of yaozhang experience?
Cao Juan: solved would be nice, to say the least, however, managed to help me out.
> ▲ Surnamed Cao prepared a complaint to court. Photograph of qilu evening news network
Officers asked
Court work lunch "credit card" is it against?
"Meals" in the name, in the private hotel credit card for a long time, and the delay closing time. Changqing District Court staff should bear the corresponding legal responsibility?
Beijing Sheng Wang Youyin lawyers games law firms has advised reporters to sort out this problem, you should first confirm that belongs to "meals". "The staff in the restaurant are meals, depending on the internal rules of the Court. "Wang Youyin said, if the Court should provide meals to employees, but does not provide for specific reasons, signed an agreement with the restaurant and take into account the financial expenditure, can be characterized as a" working lunch. " And if the employees who use the courts money dining, not included in financial expenses, were arrested for "eight rules" banned "recreational", even in serious corruption.
Earlier, in an interview with local media, involved Wang, the judge said the Court "has a unwritten rule", that is, if the staff after a late and missed the canteen for dinner, you can eat meals, "according to the agreement for reimbursement".
Wang Youyin said, in the present case, the Court has not signed a contract with restaurant in the early and late no checkout or ratify the contract payments for their employees, can be deemed "signing" is a personal act, but court staff meals at Shi Liangming identity, and righteousness "Court of claims", the alleged misuse of public power.
Beijing News reporter Wang Yu Zhang Tailing intern Wu Lin Yue edit proofreading Lu Aiying
>: Tang Kun Qu SN117
Article keywords:Courts owe meal credit card
I want feedback
Save a Web page
The Beijing News
山东一法院7年欠饭店2.4万餐费 |法院|欠餐费|挂账_新闻资讯
7年，24000元，这是济南市民曹娟(化名)挂在嘴上的两个数字。
曹娟是济南市长清区一家饭店老板，自2009年至2013年，济南市长清区人民法院执行三庭的工作人员，以“工作餐”名义，四年间共计到曹娟所开饭店用餐达300次，总金额超过24000元，全部使用“签单”形式。自2013年8月起，为讨回这些餐费，曹娟多次往返于饭店和法院之间，却屡屡碰壁。
12月6日，济南市长清区人民法院办公室一名工作人员向记者称，此事系涉事工作人员“个人行为”。而曹娟则称，在媒体介入后，长清区法院已经派出工作人员，向其以现金形式结清了欠款。
>▲饭店老板展示法院工作人员的“欠条”，显示就餐的次数和金额。 图片来源 齐鲁晚报网
饭店老板：法院工作人员组团吃饭
曹娟的饭店，位于济南市长清区大学路，长清区人民法院南侧。
这是曹娟从事餐饮业的第10个年头。早在2006年，她便在长清区人民法院附近开饭店，中间也曾承包学校食堂。
曹娟告诉记者，因为地利之便，不时有法院工作人员前来用餐，一来二去，她也因此与之相熟，其中就包括执行三庭的一名王姓法官。2009年2月份，几名工作人员在店里，聊到外出用餐的话题，上述王姓法官随之向曹娟建议，以后将她的小饭店作为“食堂”，固定在此用餐，餐费直接签单，“最后一起结账”。
在做小本生意的曹娟看来，这样的建议，无异于一张“长期饭票”。曹娟介绍，自己与这些法院工作人员平素相识，并且对方又是“法院的人”，工作稳定并且离得近。为了能够做下这单生意，尽管并没有谈清具体付款方式，曹娟仍然满嘴答应了下来。
自此以后，长清区法院的工作人员，三天两头便组团来吃饭。曹娟回忆，这些“法院的人”吃喝档次并不高，也就是普通的工作餐。每次用餐完毕后，这些账目都会被记下，然后累积。
曹娟没有想到，账本上的一串串数字，想要“变现”，需要7年。
>▲12月6日，饭店老板用
手机传来“欠条”图片。 新京报记者 王煜 摄
欠餐费已结清 法院称是“个人行为”
记者获得的一份手写欠条显示，长清区法院以“执三庭关于执行信用社案件工作餐”的名义，自2009年到2011年12月期间，在曹娟的饭店用餐共计173次，费用12440元;2012全年用餐91次，费用是7238元;2013年初到2013年7月份，这一数字达到36次，总计4400元。
欠条下部注有“执行三庭”字样，并附有两个签名。曹娟称，这两人均为执行三庭法官，其中一人即为上述王姓法官。
按照这则欠条上的信息，四年间，长清区法院的工作人员共计在曹娟的饭店用餐300次，总金额24078元，均未结账。
这些钱究竟由谁消费，又为何一直保持“挂账”的状态?在接受媒体采访时，上述王姓法官称，工作餐系“领导安排”、统一安排，统一结账“，对于欠款原因，其不愿多谈。
记者探员据此联系了涉事的济南市长清区人民法院。该院办公室一名工作人员称，曹娟所持欠条属实。而关于这部分费用，其称系当事工作人员“个人行为”，将对此进行调查。而对于王姓法官所称“领导安排”一事，上述工作人员不予置评。
法院“欠两万多元饭款7年不还”一事，很快引发舆论关注。12月6日下午，曹娟告诉记者，已有自称“长清法院工作人员”的人，携带现金来到店里，将欠款还清。
> (漫画/勾犇 原载于2016年12月6日新京报)
对话
“为要回饭钱，起诉书都写好了”
7年来，多次往返法院和饭店之间，为了讨回欠款奔走。12月6日下午，记者联系到涉事饭店老板曹娟。曹娟说，当初同意“挂账”是觉得法院是正规单位，不会欠钱，却没想到讨回餐费如此难。
记者：当初为什么会同意“挂账”?
曹娟：他们(法院的人)以前经常来我这里吃饭，也聊聊家常，都很熟。所以他们提出来的时候，就同意了。
记者：以什么名义在店里吃饭?
曹娟：就是说工作餐，好像说是要办案，有的时候需要在外面吃饭。我这边离法院近，就到这儿来了，相当于小食堂吧!
记者：一般都吃些什么?
曹娟：其实吃得很普通，两三个人几十块钱的标准。人多一些，能吃到一百多，不喝酒，吃完就走，然后我记账。
记者：记账的时候记在谁名下?
曹娟：记在常来吃工作餐的那个王法官名下，有时候也会挂在他另外一个同事的名下。
记者：第一次要账是什么时候?
曹娟：记不太清了，应该是2009年的年底。当时我算了下账，已经欠了好几千了，就想着把账结一下。
记者：要账的过程顺利吗?
曹娟：我先找到那个姓王的，然后他挺客气，说给我问问。然后问完了说，暂时没法报，让我等等。
记者：然后就一直等着?
曹娟：我是觉得，法院是正规单位，不会欠钱。后来他们再来，我还是一样招待。中间也打电话问过钱的事情，那边总是让我再等等。
记者：以什么名义拖着?
曹娟：说是要向领导请示。
记者：这笔欠款对你的生活有什么影响?
曹娟：我是做小本生意的，两万多块钱不算个小数目，拖了这么久，对饭店经营都有影响。而且，现在餐饮业难做，就一直想把这个钱要回来。
记者：想过什么办法?
曹娟：如果钱少，我就不要了，但是这笔钱不少。今年10月份，我还准备找律师起诉，要回饭钱，起诉书都写好了。
记者：后来解决了吗?
曹娟：这个事情被媒体报道后，就有人来我店里了，那个姓王的没有来。他们用现金，把两万多块钱还清了。
记者：怎么看待7年来要账的经历?
曹娟：解决了就好，别的不说了，不管怎么样，总算帮我解决了。
>▲曹女士准备好诉状欲起诉法院。 图片来源 齐鲁晚报网
探员追问
法院工作餐“挂账”是否违规?
以“工作餐”的名义，在私营饭店长期挂账，并且一再拖延结账时间。长清区法院上述工作人员，是否应当承担相应的法律责任?
北京圣运律师事务所主任王优银律师向记者表示，要理清这个问题，首先应当确认是否属于“工作餐”。“工作人员在餐厅吃饭是否属于工作餐，要看法院的内部规定。”王优银表示，如法院应为员工提供工作餐，但因特定原因不能提供，在与餐厅签订协议且计入财政支出，则可定性为“工作餐”。而如果员工私自用法院的钱就餐，并未列入财政支出，则涉嫌“八项规定”所禁止的“公款吃喝”，情形严重时甚至构成贪污。
此前，在接受当地媒体采访时，涉事王姓法官称，法院“有个不成文规定”，即如果相关工作人员出差晚归后，没有赶上食堂供饭，可以在外吃工作餐，“到时候按照协议给报销”。
王优银表示，在本案中，法院前期未与餐厅签订合同，后期也没有为员工结账或为追认款项，可以认定“签单”属工作人员个人行为，但法院工作人员在用餐时亮明身份，且对外称“法院会报销”，则涉嫌滥用公权力。
新京报记者 王煜 实习生 武琳悦 编辑 张太凌 校对 陆爱英
>责任编辑：瞿崑 SN117
文章关键词： 法院 欠餐费 挂账
我要反馈
保存网页
新京报