Go homepage(回首页) Upload pictures (上传图片) Write articles (发文字帖)
The author:(作者)aaapublished in(发表于) 2013/12/24 8:41:29 Bai Jing was infringement judgment,The court dismissed the family litigation
CNS, Beijing, December 24 (reporter Zhang Xi)-February 28, 2012, aged actor Fang Hui was killed husband Zhou Chenghai assassination at home, next week also died of suicide. On August 7 of that year, the White House broke the human giant's first Jubilee Court, denounced the violations of right of reputation. After 1 year, 23rd the Court dismissed aspirations of the Bai Jia, giant Jubilee language find the defendant refrain from speech motive is not to meet the public's prying eyes, and relevant sectors of society attention instead, does not constitute an invasion of privacy.
The verdict: Fang Hui family dismissed all the claims
23rd, accused giant Jubilee in micro-Bo Shang Sun out judgement of part content, above wrote "from giant Jubilee disclosure of event surrounding the of method and means see, its always around with inquiry Zhou Chenghai acts motivation and reported Qiao Yu acts expand, on Fang Hui of personal life satire, its using language on Fang Hui and relatives keep has due of restraint, said giant Jubilee published speech of motives not for meet public of peep desires, but hopes through makes Qiao Yu of acts was social concern then caused about sector attention. ”
Also refers to the judgement, "the association between the event and decided to mention the Qiao Yu cannot fail to mention the Fang Hui's love life. Has aroused public attention to suspected criminal acts, are important elements of citizens ' freedom of expression, privacy and freedom of expression involved in this case measured between two legal interest, freedom of expression should be protected by law. For this reason, giant Jubilee remarks reveal Fang Hui's marriage, privacy, but does not constitute a violation of privacy of Fang Hui. ”
For this reason, the verdict of the case as dismissed Fang Hui family (the plaintiff Gao Mingjie, and Bai Chunlong) all claims.
Giant Jubilee defendant: no surprise
In addition to public judgment, wrote in the giant Jubilee: "for almost two years, and finally got results! Although it won, still worrying about the White House. Not afraid of no good, just no good, and around Bai Jia is not really helping them, care for them, for the sake of their people, family, love, friendship, more indifferent at this time ... ... In fact, is money! Alas, hope they can find it! Hopes that the bad guys soon be punished! ”
Reporters for the first time giant Jubilee telephone contact to the defendant. For this verdict, he expressed "surprise" and "I have witnesses, material evidence, and I didn't do anything, my comments were directed at cases and does not relate to Fang Hui. ”
Giant Jubilee told reporters that is against his white family, is because someone in this matter, "maybe they are speculative, they hired three lawyers in this case, is not rational. "Asked why think this lawsuit is money, the huge Jubilee explained," anyway, a lot of people without pure, Bai Jia presented 1 million compensation for the year, may be the go. ”
In addition, Twitter mentioned "bad guy as soon as possible be punished", giant Jubilee admits that "men's three" Qiao Yu.
It is worth mentioning that, Qiao Yu suspected fraud trial, on July 29 of this year, Beijing second intermediate people's Court has heard were involved the Qiao Yu Zhou Chenghai, Fang Hui emotional case of suspected fraud, Qiao Yu was charged with cheating Zhou Chenghai $ 7.7 million in cash and watches, paintings and other objects, but his confession in court.
(Edit: SN091)December 24, 2013 China News Network(被杀演员白静侵权案判决 法院驳回其家人诉讼|白静|侵权案|演员_新闻资讯
中新网北京12月24日电(记者 张曦) 2012年2月28日，28岁的演员白静在家中被老公周成海刺杀身亡，随后周也自杀离世。当年8月7日，白家把当时的第一位爆料人巨春雷告上法庭，斥其侵犯名誉权。时隔1年多，法院23日驳回白家的诉求，认为被告巨春雷语言保持克制，发表言论动机不是为了满足公众的窥探欲，而是希望引起社会和有关部门重视，不构成侵犯隐私权。
判决结果：驳回白静家人全部诉讼请求
23日，被告巨春雷在微博上晒出判决书的部分内容，上面写道“从巨春雷披露的事件原委的方法和手段看，其始终围绕着探究周成海行为动因和举报乔宇行为展开，对白静的个人生活点到为止，其使用语言对白静及其亲属保持了应有的克制，表示巨春雷发表言论的动机不是为满足公众的窥视私欲，而是希冀通过使乔宇的行为被社会关注继而引起有关部门重视。”
判决书还提到，“事件之间的关联，决定了要提及乔宇就不能不提及白静的感情生活。引起社会公众对涉嫌犯罪行为的关注，是公民表达自由的重要内容，在本案涉及的隐私保护和表达自由的两个法益之间衡量，表达自由更应当受到法律保护。基于上述原因，巨春雷言论虽然披露了白静的婚姻、情变等个人隐私，但不构成侵犯白静的隐私权。”
正因如此，该案的判决结果为驳回白静家人(原告高明洁、白春龙)的全部诉讼请求。
被告巨春雷：意料之中
除了公开判决书，巨春雷还在微博中写道：“快两年了，终于有了结果！虽然赢了官司，却仍为白家担忧。不怕没好事，就怕没好人，白家身边实在没有真心帮助她们，关心她们，为她们着想的人，亲情，爱情，友情，在此刻更显得淡泊……其实，都是钱闹的！唉，希望她们能随心如愿吧！也希望坏人早日得到应有的惩罚！”
记者第一时间电话联系了被告巨春雷。对于这样的判决结果，他表示在“意料之中”，“我人证、物证都有，而且我没做什么，我发表的言论都是针对案件，并非针对白静个人。”
巨春雷告诉记者，白家人之所以会告自己，是因为背后有人在推动这件事，“或许他们是投石问路，就这么个案子他们请了仨律师，非常不理性。”问到为何认为这场官司都是钱闹的，巨春雷解释称，“反正很多人目的不纯，当年白家提出100万的赔偿，可能是奔这个去的。”
另外，对于微博提到的“坏人早日得到应有的惩罚”，巨春雷坦言就是说的“男小三”乔宇。
值得一提的是，乔宇涉嫌诈骗案也在审理中，今年7月29日，北京二中院曾公开审理被指介入周成海、白静感情的乔宇涉嫌诈骗一案，乔宇被控骗取周成海770万现金及手表、字画等物，但他当庭翻供。
赞