Google earned $ 43 billion by An Zhuonian? Larry page, denied that Oracle disappointed
Google, Android, Oracle-IT information
Oracle is moving to Google to claim billions of dollars. On Thursday, the Google Alphabet, Larry page, Chief Executive of the parent company (Larry Page) is Oracle's lawyers asked to testify in court.
Oracle's lawyers asked him to Google Android software revenue is. This is Google has never publicly discussed.
Previously, Oracle's expert witnesses had proved that Google Android created from revenues of about $ 42.3 billion , most of which is advertising revenue.
The lawyer showed page a file submitted to the Google Board of Directors. This document says,"our applications and advertising makes Android an annual revenue of $ 43 billion in ecosystem. ”
However, Paige responded in court, said: " I think that these revenues are not all of Google's revenues. ”
Paige said he considers these figures to be Android as a whole ecosystem revenue, including revenue from operators and other interested parties, not just Google's revenue.
Oracle Google claims billions of dollars, claiming that Google developed Android time to use some of its Java programming language, now it should to pay Oracle royalties and damages.
Oracle is acquiring Sun Microsystems company in 2010 and its Java programming language. Now, their argument is that the Java application programming interface (API). API can be made between the two applications work together and share data.
Paige did not let Oracle take advantage to
Paige also responded to a number of other issues on the witness stand.
When the lawyer asked why Google acquired when the company originally developed Android, Paige retorted, began to attack the core of the argument in this case focus-the Oracle acquisition of the Java programming language.
"I'm worried about phone in the market, since many mobile phones running Java programming language. "He said.
When asked if he knew that Google did not obtain authorization to use Java from the Sun company time (Yes, he did know), Paige countered, "I think we do not plagiarize Java code. ”
Paige said he thinks using the API is the industry practice. In other words, he believes that creative part of Android is not using Java code, but some programming structures. And such a programming structure everyone can freely available from other applications.
This long legal battle has entered a third stage. In previous debates, Oracle proved that Android has 9 lines of code was a copy of Java. Android contains a total of millions of lines of code. In the course of the trial, plagiarized code includes 37 API, there are about 11,000 lines of code.
Google argues that theAPI does not belong to the scope of the copyright law. Before a Court of the jury agreed with that view. (Europe also agree with this view. In 2012, the European Court of Justice judgment API does not belong to the scope of copyright law. ) , A United States appeals court overturned this decision, announced that Oracle win.
The trial will determine how much money Google Oracle should be compensated. Google's claim is that it uses the API belongs to fair use. The whole software industry are holding their breath. Many people feel that if the API is copyrighted, then the whole software industry may lead to bloodshed.
Therefore, the PEC does not let Oracle's lawyers succeed, say what they want to say.
This lawsuit is to a large extent, based on Google's Android former supervisor and Chief Engineer Andy Rubin (Andy Rubin) email. Previously, Rubin, who sent an e-mail message saying he thought some code in the Android is the copyright of Sun company, need to obtain its authorization.
In fact, in PEC to testify when Oracle lawyer rendering could be his most stinging page to page, read another e-mail from Rubin. The e-mail warned that if Google continues to use an authorized Java in Android, the company would "set up a lot of enemies. ”
The trial ended on Thursday.
谷歌靠安卓年赚430亿美元？拉里佩奇否认，甲骨文失望 -
谷歌,安卓,甲骨文 - IT资讯
甲骨文正在向谷歌索赔数十亿美元。周四，谷歌母公司Alphabet首席执行官拉里·佩奇（Larry Page）被甲骨文律师要求出庭作证。
甲骨文律师问他谷歌Android软件的营收是多少。这个数字是谷歌从未公开讨论过的。
此前，甲骨文的专家证人曾证明，谷歌从其Android创造的营收约为423亿美元，其中大部分是广告收入。
这名律师给佩奇看了一份提交给谷歌董事会的文件。这份文件称，“我们的应用程序和广告服务让Android变成了一个年营收达430亿美元的生态系统。”
但是，佩奇在法庭上回应说：“我想，这些营收并不都是谷歌的营收。”
佩奇称，他认为这些数字是整个Android生态系统的营收，包括运营商和其他相关方的营收，而不仅仅是谷歌的营收。
甲骨文向谷歌索赔数十亿美元，声称谷歌在开发Android的时候使用了它的部分Java编程语言，现在它应该向甲骨文支付版权费和赔偿费。
甲骨文是在2010年收购Sun Microsystems公司并获得其Java编程语言的。现在，它们争论的焦点是Java的应用程序编程接口（API）。API可让两款应用程序之间协同工作，并分享数据。
佩奇没让甲骨文占到便宜
佩奇在证人席上还回答了其他一些问题。
当律师问谷歌为何收购最初开发Android的那家公司时，佩奇反唇相讥，开始抨击此案中争论的核心焦点问题——甲骨文收购的Java编程语言。
“我很担心现在市面上的手机，因为其中很多手机都运行着Java编程语言。”他说。
在被问及他是否知道谷歌并没有从Sun公司那里获得使用Java的授权时（是的，他确实知道），佩奇反驳说，“我认为，我们并没有抄袭Java代码。”
佩奇称，他认为使用API是行业惯例。换而言之，他认为Android使用的不是Java代码的创意部分，而是一些编程结构。而这些编程结构是人人都可以从其他应用程序中免费获得的。
这场旷日持久的官司已进入到了第三个阶段。在此前的争论中，甲骨文证明，Android有9行代码抄袭了Java。Android总共包含有数百万行代码。在此次审理过程中，涉嫌抄袭的代码包括37个API，大约有1.1万行代码。
谷歌辩称，API不属于版权法保护的范围。此前一家法院的陪审团也同意了这种观点。（欧洲也认同这种观点。在2012年，欧洲法院曾判定API不属于版权法保护的范畴。）但是，一家美国上诉法院推翻了这种判定，宣布甲骨文获胜。
此次审判将确定谷歌应赔偿甲骨文多少钱。谷歌现在的主张是，它使用API属于合理使用。整个软件行业也屏住了呼吸。很多人感到，如果API真的受版权法保护，那么整个软件行业可能会掀起腥风血雨。
因此，佩奇并没有让甲骨文律师得逞，说出他们想要的说法。
这起官司在很大程度上基于谷歌Android前主管兼首席工程师安迪·鲁宾（Andy Rubin）的电子邮件。此前，鲁宾曾发送电子邮件称，他认为Android中的少部分代码的版权属于Sun公司，需要获得它的授权。
事实上，在佩奇出庭作证的时候，甲骨文律师最刺痛佩奇的可能就是他呈现给佩奇看的另一封来自鲁宾的电子邮件。该电子邮件警告称，如果谷歌继续在Android中使用未获得授权的Java，该公司可能会“一路上树立不少敌人。”
此次法庭审理在周四结束。