School of professors were Fang zhouzi, exposure of misconduct: letters _ when academic papers | | | article news

Original title: hit a Professor revealed misconduct schools responded to our exclusive

Harbin city, China Youth online, June 5 (online journalist Wang Qing in the China Youth Daily: Lv Boxiong) recently, Fang in new threads on the blog to contemporary Han Xueyu – high grade of the international academic journal "thesis" theme on crash Act found in Miao Xin, a professor with Harbin Institute of technology school of management academic misconduct. Fang points out in the article, Miao Xin wrote in nature, the journal Science reflects China's one hundred or two hundred letters of the word, "high quality academic papers" included on behalf of CVS. Fang said that academic misconduct and portrayed in the novel the siege of academic fraud Han Xueyu "great minds think alike". Fang also questioned calls, you need to check the "thesis" as Miao Xin honors with research projects play a role?

5th, Harbin Institute of technology said in an exclusive response to this, Miao Xin did in school professional titles evaluation material and personnel selection to fill out this type of "paper", but not as a basis for evaluation and selection.

Fang said in the article, Miao Xin in their resume, "nearly three years the main academic paper" column in seven in the United Kingdom in nature (Nature), one in the United States in science (Science) of the "thesis", found in its original form, the "thesis" is one hundred or two hundred-word chunks of reviews, readers ' letters. For example, Fang said, Miao Xin published scientific papers on Science Ethics: young scientists voice, only more than 100 characters, is science, selected letters on scientific issues, but Miao Xin under his personal information on the page will be categorized as its own "nearly three years the main academic paper" résumés.

Fang also said the domestic industry now pay attention in international academic journals, especially the high grade of the international academic journal papers, these papers is a member of the professional title evaluation and outcome of the capital. And a high level international journals such as Miao Xin "crash" internally there has been general routine is writing letters to these journals, comments on a paper published in the journal new, or reflect the situation in China, printed, is equivalent to the published paper.

China Youth Daily: China Youth online journalists retrieve to verify, Miao Xin nearly 3 years published in the nature of the seven "thesis", in nature communications program, about 200 words. 2014, Miao Xin in natural communications column published has topics for education: China General University running target of adjustment of 232 Word communications articles Shi, Harbin University of technology news network published has entitled administered by College teachers and students in < natural > published communications articles a paper be reported, and in online can retrieved to of Harbin University of technology management College 2014 College memorabilia in the, the hospital will this a articles of published as "College research work again create success" of 6 items results one of.

According to Google snapshot capture on May 31 this year, 10:46, Miao Xin, the school teacher's information on individual pages of the Web site, these "paper" as "nearly three years the main academic paper". But for now, his personal page "in recent years, main article" into the "Article Type" (paper type) of articles and "type of Letter" (communication) articles. Among them, the Fang in the naming of the 8 articles in nature and the science of "papers" have been reclassified to "type of Letter" (communication) articles.

Miao Xin teachers ' information on your personal page also mentioned that Miao Xin, Professor, mentor, United Kingdom, Oxford University Harbin Institute of technology, Hong Kong academics, employment of young talents program entrants is responsible for more than more than 10 national and provincial research projects, published more than 40 articles, which as the first author or corresponding author of SCI, SSCI articles, more than 20 papers.

5th afternoon, Harbin University of technology on thing to China Youth reported exclusive do has written response, the response said Miao Xin in participation school within technology positions titles and talent selection Shi, does have will the class "papers" and academic papers together submitted of situation, at, judges are consistent think the class "papers" cannot as academic level evaluation of according to, but does not effect "on he of research potential and research give has is high of evaluation". According to colleagues Miao Xin, Miao Xin himself apart from this "paper", there are many other high level academic papers.

Harbin Institute of technology provides a hit on Miao Xin "employment of young talents program" in the peer table, "specific comments" column under "Miao Xin's academic contributions, published in nature and science estimates that may be critical of something, rather than a research paper, a few problems as a basis for major academic contribution. "But it also refers to" Miao Xin material, this is an outstanding young scholar, at risk and application management area, in the area of environmental governance, do a lot of research ... ... Published many academic papers both in English, is a great potential of outstanding scholars, the adoption of ' best appointment plan. ' "

Harbin Institute of technology offers a hit of "employment of young talents program" peer Miao Xin wrote also a similar assessment in the form of, "have great potential for research and development, more prominent results, it is recommended that ' natural ' and ' science ' never be evaluated article, because the article does not represent the policy papers. ”

Harbin is also exclusive to the China Youth daily said in response, "school to the academic level of each teacher finds are very stringent, and any attempt to fish in troubled waters, muddling through will not succeed. For this type of comments published in well-known foreign academic journals articles and policy articles, schools will only be regarded as a reference of teachers ' sense of social responsibility in, not as a basis for evaluation of academic level. ”

Responsible editor: Wang Hao

Article keywords:
Papers for academic articles in Harbin

I want feedback
Save a Web page
China Youth daily

哈工大教授遭方舟子曝光学术不端:信件当论文|论文|学术|文章_新闻资讯

　　原标题：哈工大一教授被曝学术不端 学校对本网独家回应

　　中青在线哈尔滨6月5日电(王尧 中国青年报·中青在线记者 吕博雄) 近日，方舟子在新语丝博客上以《当代韩学愈——高档次国际学术期刊“论文”速成法》为题，揭发哈尔滨工业大学管理学院教授苗鑫有学术不端行为。方舟子在文中指出，苗鑫将写给《自然》、《科学》杂志反映中国问题的一两百字的读者来信，以“高质量学术论文”的名义列入个人简历。方舟子称这种学术不端行为与小说《围城》里刻画过的学术骗子韩学愈“英雄所见略同”。方舟子还发出质问称，需要查一查这些“论文”是否为苗鑫获得荣誉与科研项目发挥作用？

　　5日下午，哈尔滨工业大学给本报的独家回应中称，苗鑫确实在校内职称评聘和人才选聘材料填写过此类“论文”，但并未作为评聘和选聘依据。

　　方舟子在该文章中称，苗鑫在其个人简历的“近三年主要学术论文”中列了七篇发在英国《自然》(Nature)、一篇发在美国《科学》(Science)上的“论文”，查其原文，这些“论文”就是一两百字的豆腐块评论、读者来信。方舟子还举例介绍说，苗鑫刊登于《科学》上的论文《科学道德：年轻科学家们发声》，只有一百余字，是《科学》关于科学问题的读者来信选登，但苗鑫在他的教师个人信息页面上将其归为自己”近三年主要学术论文“放入简历。

　　方舟子还称，现在国内科技界讲究在国际学术期刊，尤其是高档次的国际学术期刊发论文，这些论文更是评职称、评院士和报成果的资本。而像苗鑫这种发高水平国际期刊论文的“速成方法”，国内早已有之，大致套路是给这些期刊写读者来信，评论该期刊新发表的某篇论文，或者反映中国的情况，登出来了，就相当于在该期刊发了论文。

　　中国青年报·中青在线记者检索核实，苗鑫近3年发布在《自然》上的七篇“论文”，均发在《自然》通信栏目，200字左右。2014年，苗鑫在《自然》通信栏目发表了题目为《教育：中国一般大学办学目标的调整》的232字通讯文章时，哈尔滨工业大学新闻网发表了题为《经管学院师生在<自然>发表通讯文章》一文予以报道，并且在网上可检索到的《哈尔滨工业大学管理学院2014年学院大事记》中，该院将这一文章的发表列为“学院科研工作再创佳绩”的6项成绩之一。

　　根据谷歌快照截图，在今年5月31日10:46，苗鑫在该校网站的教师信息个人页面上，上述“论文”仍注为“近三年主要学术论文”。但目前，他的个人页面将“近年主要文章”分为了“Article类型”(论文类型)的文章和“Letter类型”(通信类型)的文章。其中，方舟子点名指出的8篇发在《自然》和《科学》上的“论文”都被重新归类为“Letter类型”(通信类型)的文章。

　　苗鑫的教师信息个人页面上还提到，苗鑫为教授、博士生导师、英国牛津大学博士后、香江学者、哈尔滨工业大学青年拔尖人才选聘计划入选者，负责国家级与省部级科研项目10余项，发表文章40余篇，其中作为第一作者或通讯作者的SCI、SSCI文章20余篇。

　　5日下午，哈尔滨工业大学就此事向中国青年报独家做了书面回应，该回应称苗鑫在参与校内技术职务评聘和人才评选时，确有将该类“论文”与学术论文一并提交的情况，当时，评委们一致认为该类“论文”不能作为学术水平评价的依据，但并未影响“对他的科研潜力和科研成果给予了很高的评价”。据苗鑫的同事介绍，苗鑫本人除了这类“论文”，还有很多其他高水平学术论文。

　　在哈尔滨工业大学提供的一份关于苗鑫的《哈工大“青年拔尖人才选聘计划”同行评议表》中，“具体评价意见”一栏下提到“在苗鑫提出的学术贡献中，在nature和science上的发表估计可能属于评论性的东西，而不是研究论文，作为主要学术贡献的依据还是有些问题的。”但也提到了“从苗鑫的材料看，这是一个杰出的年轻学者，在风险及应用管理领域、在环境治理领域等承担了大量的研究课题……发表了很多中英文学术论文，是一个极具潜力的优秀学者，建议通过‘拔尖聘任计划’”。

　　哈尔滨工业大学提供的另一份《哈工大“青年拔尖人才选聘计划”同行评议表》中也写道对苗鑫类似的评价，“具有较大的科研发展潜力，成果也比较突出，建议对于‘自然’和‘科学’文章不要过分评价，因为政策性的文章并不能代表学术论文。”

　　哈尔滨工业大学还在给中国青年报的独家回应中称，“学校对每一位老师学术水平的认定都十分严格，任何企图浑水摸鱼、蒙混过关的行为都不会得逞。对于这类发表在国外著名学术期刊上的评论性文章和政策性文章，学校只将其看做一个教师社会责任意识的体现来参考，而不作为学术水平评价依据。”

责任编辑：王浩成

文章关键词：
论文 学术 文章 哈尔滨

我要反馈
保存网页
中国青年报